The early XS1-XS1B, up to who knows when, used the P/N# 256-12231-00-00. This early front guide had a flat surface, not bowed, without the channel shape. It was superceded to the current bowed/channel style, who-knows-when. Pics of the two styles are in my album:
http://www.xs650.com/media/albums/1640/
One of the real serious issues with these is separation/delamination of the bond to the aluminum backing. 5Twins has some good pics of this separation, and on close inspection, sure 'nuff, I found it occurring on my early version as well. Started researching bonding agents for aluminum, and found many disappointing reports.
There's some good aluminum bonding agents in the aircraft industry, but I only used one of those (very expensive, but not rated for heat/oil environment), and forgot what it was. It was the replacement for the failed 'purple passion' bonding agent used in the construction of early Jim Bede designed AA-1's and AA-5's.
With the recent advent of the new semi-aluminum Ford F-150, there's been a lot of buzz about the new bonding agents used for the tricky aluminum to steel joints. Haven't seen any of that buzz covering this aluminum/plastic bonding issue though.
In the mid '70s, we had a major recall of the camchain tensioners on the first models of the Honda CB-360. The original black-plastic bow type rear tensioner (very similar design to the later XS-650 rear tensioner) had a problem with excessive wear and maintaining tension (the bow shape). The replacement tensioners were made from a different material. Replaced dozens of those tensioners. The new ones looked identical to the old ones, and you had to be careful to not mix them up. Never found out what the materials were.
The takeaway from this is: Unless you have good insider info on this design, you could easily choose a material that may not hold up...