xs EFI conversion fuel system issues

Jusblowit

Certified Looney
Messages
31
Reaction score
54
Points
18
Location
Toronto, ON, Canada
I'm on the very last leg of this project that has taken several years to get to this point...
http://www.xs650.com/threads/f-i-2-forced-induction×fuel-injection.56603/page-2#post-681076
It's (among other things) an EFI conversion run on Microsquirt.
Actually I shouldn't say I'm on the last leg because each one of the past four weekends was going to be the one when I fired it up for the first time...and then some unforeseen problem surfaces.. Yesterday was no exception.

I'm using this regulator:
https://www.jegs.com/i/Holley/510/1...hTXQqefEWjSYl4Tt1WoMmZjm0Sks6Y5AEOvcNSF3FcoD#

The fuel system flow chart, as recommended by Holley, is as follows:
Tank>pre filter>gravity feed into inline fuel pump>post filter>fuel rail>return line>bypass fuel pressure regulator(w/take-off for pressure gauge)>fuel tank return port.

Wiring, as recommended by the suppliers of microsquirt is such that the fuel pump relay is controlled by the ECU. It turns on for 2 seconds when the ignition is turned on which is meant to pressurize the system. It will then turn off and come on again only when the ECU reads a tach signal i.e. during cranking and running. This relay also powers the injectors and coils. This is a safety feature.

I put gas in the tank for the first time and pressurized the fuel system by running the fuel pump in test mode to check for any leaks. The tank, fittings, and all the lines are good, no leaks, but two problems popped up:

1. Tank venting:
Fuel seeps out past the seal of the filler cap when the system is pressurized. At first I thought my return port was squirting the returned fuel at the underside of the cap. But the more I think about it the more I am convinced that I'm building positive pressure in the tank, forcing out vapour. This seems to be confirmed as when I put the bike away , bringing it in from the chilly air to heated inside, I noticed the same thing happening even though the system hadn't been pressurized in at least 20 minutes.

The filler cap has a rubber diaphragm one-way check valve that allows air to enter but nothing to escape. This probably works for carbed bikes which with no return line, only draw fuel OUT of the tank and need to let in air to avoid a vacuum, but with the pressure created by the high pressure pump I seem to be building pressure in the tank that has no escape route. I need a vent that will allow positive pressure to escape - online research confirms that factory EFI bikes have a provision for this.. This raises a safety concern. without a check valve, what is stopping fuel from leaking if the bike finds itself on it's side? With many old bikes, the answer is nothing. Actually a friends' 2011 ("new" by comparison) Ducati Monster recently got knocked over while parked by some anonymous do-gooder... when it was found in the morning gas had spilled all over the tank peeling the paint off one of the plastics. So maybe the answer is bikes just have an open vent? Many dirt bikes do... but dirt and plastic don't spark like metal and asphalt if you go down... there is such a thing as a rollover ball valve that cars utilize... they're kind of large tho and I think they would only work if you landed completely upside down as opposed to on your side, as a bike would. Just ordered one of these:
https://fortnine.ca/en/moose-vent-cap
But I'm not sure that it's not just a one way check valve (air in, nothing out) which I already have.

If the answer is just "open vent" then all I have to do is remove the diaphragm form my filler cap vent, but I'm wondering if there's a safer way?

2. Fuel pressure
For one, the fuel pump priming pulse that the ECU fires isn't long enough to get the system up to the required pressure (43psi). Not a problem, the length of that is programmable. The trickier thing is the regulator doesn't hold pressure with the pump not running. I knew that aftermarket regulators did not, as opposed to the OEMs, but I thought it would be on the order of minutes. It's not- at least not with this regulator, as soon as the pump turns off, the pressure drops back to zero within seconds. The practical implication is that if I don't hit the starter immediately at the end of the prime pulse I will have to crank for 3-4-5 seconds untill pressure builds again. That can't be good for the battery....and forget about kick starting. Not sure if other aftemarket regulators are any different.... read on the Aeromotive (about as expensive a regulator as you can buy) website something about how this is a feature not a bug, and that the OEMs retaining pressure for 30 minuted is an EPA requirement and actually compromises performance, although they don't say how.

One idea is to wire in a momentary switch that holds the fuel pump on prior to hitting the starter... perhaps I could use the clutch safety switch that currently is not in use... ? Those who have done it, what did you do?
 
I am no Expert on this system so disregard this if wrong
And no expert on injection at all
I believed on some system ( common rail ? ) the priming start pressuring goes on until a pressure sensor stops
pressure build.
This because the electronically regulated injector have the prescribed pressure
I further believed that these pressurized " Common Rail " are tight so they don't loose pressure if left standing.
There are precautions to observe when working on fex Honda fireblades

My first assumption
as soon as the pump turns off, the pressure drops back to zero within seconds

Would be a leaking Coupling or injector or so --- disregard this if entirely wrong
 
Ok, I did my fuel system a bit different. I have an intank pump setup, using a sportster 1200 pump and a ninja650 fuel pressure regulator. It slowly bleeds pressure off when the pump is off, probably 15 seconds or so to drop off to 20psi. It holds between 40 and 45psi running. Being a returnless set up I don't build pressure in the tank. Part of it might be the pump heats the fuel causing more vapor.
I had a cheap ebay FPR on a triumph spitfire and it would hold pressure for 10 minutes and drop maybe 5 psi.
 
Is that just a ball valve? I just ordered something similar. I'm just wondering- seems like those are designed to block flow when fully inverted. would it hold back the fuel if it was on it's side? when did a bike ever go down and land wheels up? I'm sure it's happened but not often...
 
I am no Expert on this system so disregard this if wrong
And no expert on injection at all
I believed on some system ( common rail ? ) the priming start pressuring goes on until a pressure sensor stops
pressure build.
This because the electronically regulated injector have the prescribed pressure
I further believed that these pressurized " Common Rail " are tight so they don't loose pressure if left standing.
There are precautions to observe when working on fex Honda fireblades

My first assumption
as soon as the pump turns off, the pressure drops back to zero within seconds

Would be a leaking Coupling or injector or so --- disregard this if entirely wrong

Yes, as I understand it most OEM systems (bike/car) remain pressurized long after the engine is shut down. from what I gather aftermarket regulators behave differently though. I know I don't have a leak, It's just how the regulator works. From Ratranger's post it would seem there are differences between units so some trial and error would be needed.
 
Ok, I did my fuel system a bit different. I have an intank pump setup, using a sportster 1200 pump and a ninja650 fuel pressure regulator. It slowly bleeds pressure off when the pump is off, probably 15 seconds or so to drop off to 20psi. It holds between 40 and 45psi running. Being a returnless set up I don't build pressure in the tank. Part of it might be the pump heats the fuel causing more vapor.
I had a cheap ebay FPR on a triumph spitfire and it would hold pressure for 10 minutes and drop maybe 5 psi.

Ok, going with a repurposed bike specific system would have probably been easier... but i'm too far down the road for that. thanks for the info anyhow.
 
Ok, update- What we have here is a classic example of what the head doctors call "catastrophising" ...
aka "it's not as bad as it seems". Lesson learned- fully diagnose the problem before trying to engineer a solution.

I made a quick little temporary cap out of a piece of plexiglass, fitted to the tank and ran the pump to get a visual. The flow from the return line is a pretty mellow trickle, wouldn't hit the filler opening even if there was no cap at all. I could also see bubbles pushing out the bolt holes after running for a bit- definitely building positive pressure.

Solution- Removed the flap from the check valve in the filler cap and run as an open vent. Reinstalled improved splash shield that will catch any spray from the return port just in case. Ball valve is in the mail, I'll install that somehow later, directly to the cap or inline in a vent tube.

-This immediately fixed the pressure buildup, no leaks/seapage:).
-It also changed how the regulator builds/maintains pressure. Either I still had air in the lines because with the fuel seeping out the cap I never ran it long enough to fully purge, or the pump+regulator were fighting the pressure buildup in the tank. Either way, with the open vent now the pressure only drops to around 20psi after the initial priming pulse, where it stays for some time, and then jumps to the specified 43psi setting pretty much instantly when the pump comes on again. So problem solved.

I did get a chance to try starting up last night- I got a few starts but it would die right away. Have to tweak the startup fueling settings no doubt. didn't have time to keep messing with it. Long weekend coming up- I'm sure i can wake the dragon!:unsure:
 
It takes some tweaking to get startup right. I ended up using a ford IACV to let extra air in on startup to raise the idle. Once I got that set up and working well start ups were much smoother. Here's a cold start on mine after redoing the trans.
 
If you have room the honda ATV fuel pumps are a simple solution. It's seperate from the tank, so you need a feed and return line, but but the pump and pressure regulator are all in 1 unit.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/New-Genuine-Honda-Fuel-Pump-Shadow-VT750-VT1300-TRX680-Rincon-Notes-T107/272256620958?fits=Make:Honda&epid=1329825412&hash=item3f63c2599e:g:F48AAOSwzrxUwTVH

That looks bigger than the inline Bosch I am using , I should post a pic of all the plumbing under the seat with all the blower in/out/bypass lines ... It's TIGHT. Couldn't possibly for anything more. At any rate- that looks like an in-tank unit? And is the pressure adjustable? All academic anyway, as with the pressure relieved the current setup works well.
 
It's bigger than a standard inline pump, because it's basically an intank setup mounted in its own surge tank. So it mounts vertically, and could be fit where the stock airbox is. But it's not compact, or adjustable. But honda used it on the rincon 680 and the vt750 and a few others. If you have room it's a simple solution.
 
If you have room the honda ATV fuel pumps are a simple solution. It's seperate from the tank, so you need a feed and return line, but but the pump and pressure regulator are all in 1 unit.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/New-Genuine-Honda-Fuel-Pump-Shadow-VT750-VT1300-TRX680-Rincon-Notes-T107/272256620958?fits=Make:Honda&epid=1329825412&hash=item3f63c2599e:g:F48AAOSwzrxUwTVH
Do you know what the connections are on these regulator/pumps? They don't seem to be marked and parts lists are vague...
 
Might try some starter fluid between the MAF and the throttle body to get it started to see how it does with some throttle to see if the mixture is rich or lean.
 
Might try some starter fluid between the MAF and the throttle body to get it started to see how it does with some throttle to see if the mixture is rich or lean.
Thanks for the reply. Apologies - I wasn't clear on what I am asking - the Honda pump/regulator unit has three fluid outlets - two large and a smaller barbed one. Is the unit a constant return to tank or a "dead head" (no tank return) system? Which outlet goes to the fuel tank feed, which to the injectors and what does the third outlet do?
 
I did get a chance to try starting up last night- I got a few starts but it would die right away. Have to tweak the startup fueling settings no doubt. didn't have time to keep messing with it. Long weekend coming up- I'm sure i can wake the dragon!:unsure:

Might try some starter fluid between the MAF and the throttle body to get it started to see how it does with some throttle to see if the mixture is rich or lean.
 
the Honda pump/regulator unit has three fluid outlets - two large and a smaller barbed one. Is the unit a constant return to tank or a "dead head" (no tank return) system? Which outlet goes to the fuel tank feed, which to the injectors and what does the third outlet do?
The fuel lines are covered in the parts description.
Screen Shot 2022-07-22 at 5.34.00 AM.png
 
Thanks. So the "Hose, Fuel Feed" goes from the tank to the pump, the "Tube, Fuel" goes to the injectors and the "breather" back to the top of the tank???
 
Back
Top