Power Tool Safety Question

Downeaster

Everything in XS
Messages
3,550
Reaction score
24,017
Points
513
Location
Downeast Maine
Watched a video on shop tips this morning and one of the recommendations was running your table saw via a foot switch.

Personally, I think this is a bad idea and safety hazard. Inadvertently stepping ON the switch and starting the saw, or foot slipping OFF the switch in the middle of a rip cut.

I would NEVER do such a thing and I'm the furthest thing from a Safety Nazi.

What does the hive mind think?
 
I think such a footswitch would have to be shrouded to prevent accidental operation.

Forgive me for thinking that turning a saw off halfway through a cut isn't a safety issue. It's inconvenient.
Shroud is a good point.

My thinking on the stop-in-cut issue is kickback. 99% of my tablesaw work is solo and handling a 4x8 sheet of plywood or a 12 foot stick of dimensional lumber is challenging enough without factoring a foot switch into the equation.

JMHO of course.
 
Well at table saw speed of disaster the switch won't make a damned bit of difference.
Cough. Cut up some fingers badly in a table saw cutting foam sheet. Docs pinned em back together and they work "good enough".
There are some table saw quick stops available now that seem pretty amazing ...
 
Thereby creating a trip hazard. Again, JMHO.
I say that from experience where I now work, with a couple hydraulic presses that had foot pedal actuators that are never where you want them to be, have a shroud over them so you don't step on them accidentally but if you don't slide your foot in exactly you end up pushing it aside
 
Watched a video on shop tips this morning and one of the recommendations was running your table saw via a foot switch.

Personally, I think this is a bad idea and safety hazard. Inadvertently stepping ON the switch and starting the saw, or foot slipping OFF the switch in the middle of a rip cut.

I would NEVER do such a thing and I'm the furthest thing from a Safety Nazi.

What does the hive mind think?
We have them on one of our CNC mills to close the hydraulic vises. As has been already pointed out, a shroud is essential to help prevent accidental closings and smooshed fingers.

It does not, however, completely eliminate stupidity.

I personally, however, hate standing and using the foot pedal on my TIG welder. Fucks up my balance and makes me weld even worse than I already do.

I say thumbs down to the switchness.
 
Well at table saw speed of disaster the switch won't make a damned bit of difference.
Cough. Cut up some fingers badly in a table saw cutting foam sheet. Docs pinned em back together and they work "good enough".

I used to work in a lumber yard that had a number of saws in continual action. Days are long and the work monotonous, makes you lose your focus. Lotta guys named nicknamed Stubby. 😲
 
Last edited:
My H.S. daze we had shop classes.
One was wood, so I build 2 18"x18"x 30" speaker cabinets.

I went with some good stuff, mahogany 3/4" ply.

First try was great, then second cut grabbed and chucked it into my belt buckle.

Not to worry, fall off the horse/get back on.

Third cut grabbed, I knew the sound of what was occur.
Stepped out of the way and it kicked back 10 feet and knocked down a ladder.

Guards were not in fashion in 1975.

Still have the monster speakers to this day.

Keep the cut straight!
 
Well at table saw speed of disaster the switch won't make a damned bit of difference.
Cough. Cut up some fingers badly in a table saw cutting foam sheet. Docs pinned em back together and they work "good enough".
There are some table saw quick stops available now that seem pretty amazing ...
Yes, some high end table saws has an "emergency brake pad" that jams into the blade and stops it pretty much instantly. The sensor device somehow monitors change im the capacitance of the blade, cutting "meat" changes capacitance from when cutting wood or similar. Pretty darn impressive tech.
Check it out:
 
I used to work in a lumber yard that had a number of saws in continual action. Days are long and the work monotonous, makes you lose your focus. Lotta guys named Stubby. 😲
I worked at a sheet metal shop bending sheet metal Hydraulic press brake
Half weeks 8 hour shifts impossible stay focused. Same parts In and Out.
There was a foot pedal for pressing and the gap how much the press opened was adjustable
from the small gap thickness metal to larger.
One colleague shortened two fingers on the right hand when a strip slipped he automatically put his hand at the wrong place
Stepping on the pedal.

I adjusted the gap so it was impossible stick in a finger . Bossman adjusted it wider Shouting .. takes ... to long time for the work .
Scolding me .I adjusted it back and it kept on a while I was prepared getting fired but the boss gave up.
I kept the job and all fingers.
Pay was not good and monotonous and dangerous So I reckon it was not so easy Hire .Should someone get fired.

These saws are dangerous and hand held as well So was Chain saws for Lumberjacks . back in the day the stops was not good
It could grab and throw the saw up around and hit the person on the Shoulder
I have met one where the Chainsaw bounced onto the left hand Terrible.

I take chances with machinery at times but not with these saws or Axes .. Terrible life changing accidents in a split second.
The hand held ones I adjust cutting height.

Some press machinery had buttons that was needed to be pressed left and right at the same time
Without that it would not close . if it is the type of saw I believe it spins and runs ... Dont se what a pedal can do. . No stop
I se people use a stump of wood feeding the wood to be sawed.
 
I was prepared getting fired but the boss gave up.
I kept the job and all fingers.

Some press machinery had buttons that was needed to be pressed left and right at the same time
Without that it would not close.
I will do anything my bosses ask of me. Hell, I'll fucking hop on one leg and bark like a dog as long as they're paying me.

But I won't risk my own safety.



I worked at a bearing manufacturer and to loosen the outer race after it got swaged around the ball, these (maybe 4" round) hardened steel rollers would approach from either side and massage the race a little bit to grow it. So the operator would put a bearing in the machine, then she or he had to use both hands to hold down levers on each side of the machine for the rollers to come in.

One guy (not me, I swear) was getting crazy high production untill the super came by and noticed that he tied one of the levers down with some string and a chunk of scrap metal sitting on the floor so he didn't have to take extra time to move one of his hands from one of the levers to retrieve that part.

Supervisor canned the guy on the spot for egregiously bypassing safety features. Told him to grab his shit and get the fuck out and they'd mail him his paycheck.

It wasn't the best company to work for in terms of pay, but they didn't fuck around when it came to safety, I'll give 'em that much.
 
Yes, some high end table saws has an "emergency brake pad" that jams into the blade and stops it pretty much instantly. The sensor device somehow monitors change im the capacitance of the blade, cutting "meat" changes capacitance from when cutting wood or similar. Pretty darn impressive tech.
Check it out:
they are impressive, however i would not use a finger to test its ability to stop on the spot
 
99% of my tablesaw work is solo and handling a 4x8 sheet of plywood or a 12 foot stick of dimensional lumber is challenging enough without factoring a foot switch into the equation.

That’s why all my panel cutting is now done with a tracksaw or circular saw and straightedge.
 
Back
Top