IIRC, they are slightly different, due to the change from 5 to 6 clutch discs. I read somewhere that the newer one will fit fine on the older cases, but the older one will not match up as well to the newer cases.
I use a 1981 6 pack clutch on my 75; replaced the original 7 pack with the late model spring loaded unit, so we know that covers from 73-81 should work.
Here's a note on clutch packs pulled from here:
http://thexscafedotcom.wordpress.com/2011/01/19/xs650-clutch-assembly/
CLUTCH PACKS
There are 3 variations. Pre 73, 6 plate pack : 73-78, 7 plate pack : post 78, spring loaded 6 plate pack.
The different packs, 6-7-6 plates, are interchangeable as a unit. The early, thicker plates (3.5mm) are not available anymore. If it hasn’t already long been done the rubber rings are removed and extra steel and friction plates are installed.
The 7 plate pack is known to increase risk of primary gear dampening spring failure.
Steel Pressure Friction
Pre Aug 73 1.6mm 6 @ 3.5 mm
Aug 73 – Aug 78 1.4 mm 7 @ 3.0 mm
Post Aug 78 1.4 mm 6 @ 3.0 mm
My personal suggestion is to change in a later model 6 plate pack – straight swap.
When installing:…
soak new friction plates in oil-overnight if possible…Note that your bike needs 20W-40, which is available at truck stops and auto stores…eg Shell Rotella, Pennzoil without the additives found in modern automobile motor oils. Wrong oil = clutch problems…big time!!!
check steel plates for warping-lay on plate glass, if you can rock it or slide a 0.008″(0.2mm) feeler guage under, replace
buff the sharp edges smooth…as these are stamped-out, the top edges are rounded by the die, the bottom edges are left sharp…buff these smooth with a wire wheel
scuff the surfaces lightly with emery paper to remove glazing – wash
check friction plates for wear…new-3.0mm…min-2.7mmm (earlier, 3.5mm new/3.1mm min)
lightly bevel the edges of the friction plate tabs with a file…this helps prevent them catching on the basket fingers
NOTE…when installing the later sprung 6 plate pack, be aware that there are 2 different steel plates…the plate that belongs to the anti loading pack that goes into the boss first, is thicker than the others, 1.6mm as opposed to 1.4mm – dont mix them up