Soliddrummer
XS650 Addict
Yes, you will need a new gear, that one is beyond useable in my opinion. Some wear is still acceptable, due to the nature of how the gear engages, but that one is too far gone. I had the same problem, no amount of spring tensin will help with a gear that worn, I was able to find a good used one on eBay, clamp the u shaped end of the wishbone spring into a vice a little, and reinstall on the new gear, problem solved. Good luck!