Yet Another Clutch Mod. Thread

Jim

Beyond the edge is the unknown. Here be Dragons
Top Contributor
XS650.com Supporter
Messages
14,445
Reaction score
56,250
Points
813
Location
Kansas City Mo.
I mean who doesn't like one forearm bigger than the other, lol. Nice job on the modification!
:lmao: Right... symmetry is highly overrated. The forearms of my youth would laugh at the idea of an "easy" clutch pull.

Me in the first gulf war (1991)
Jim 1.jpg
 

billy icon

test pilot,gunnie pig, and all around experiment
Messages
475
Reaction score
943
Points
93
Location
mt hood OR
very cool JIM. I thought my life long mechanics hands where worn haha, I had a chick ask me how iold I was a week ago I said guees, she said let me see your hands... she guessed 10 years over, thats what we get for working for a living,
'
so Im not going to spoil it yet, but in my engine build thread I will show what "conversion" ive been doing with all the xs bikes I build, and it makes the clutch sooooo easy and smooth to pul you cant even belive it, its a suprise, stay tuned
 

Jim

Beyond the edge is the unknown. Here be Dragons
Top Contributor
XS650.com Supporter
Messages
14,445
Reaction score
56,250
Points
813
Location
Kansas City Mo.
so Im not going to spoil it yet, but in my engine build thread I will show what "conversion" ive been doing with all the xs bikes I build, and it makes the clutch sooooo easy and smooth to pul you cant even belive it, its a suprise, stay tuned
In school we had a name for girls like you. ;)
 

Jim

Beyond the edge is the unknown. Here be Dragons
Top Contributor
XS650.com Supporter
Messages
14,445
Reaction score
56,250
Points
813
Location
Kansas City Mo.
I got the springtime wake-up chores done.... well, mostly. :rolleyes: Good enough to give it a test anyway. After warming it up for a few minutes, I dropped it into first and got a definite thunk instead of it's normal click. I played with the adjusters on the perch and the actuator and finally got it to the point where it would go into and out of gear fairly easy... but not as easy as it used to do. Toodled 'round the hood for about 30 min. Back roads... lots of stop and go... got it nice and hot and it stayed about the same. Played with adjustment some more and got it to the point where neutral was fairly easy to find... again, not as easy as it used to be... but tolerable. Here's the problem though, adjustment is on a hairs edge. Any movement one way or the other will cause either slipping or drag... there's no margin on either side. I'm guessin that adjustment would be a constant, almost daily battle.
So.... on to V.2. I'll TIG the hole closed and re-drill it at 45mm. That's still 10mm better than the existing 35mm length.
As far as riding and shifting, it was almost effortless. Like a hot knife thru butter. :D
 
Last edited:

MaxPete

Lucille, Betty, Demi & Gretel: I ask, THEY decide.
Top Contributor
XS650.com Supporter
Messages
9,269
Reaction score
29,215
Points
688
Location
near Harrow, ON, Canada
I got the springtime wake-up chores done.... well, mostly. :rolleyes: Good enough to give it a test anyway. After warming it up for a few minutes, I dropped it into first and got a definite thunk instead of it's normal click. I played with the adjusters on the perch and the actuator and finally got it to the point where it would go into and out of gear fairly easy... but not as easy as it used to do. Toodled 'round the hood for about 30 min. Back roads... lots of stop and go... got it nice and hot and it stayed about the same. Played with adjustment some more and got it to the point where neutral was fairly easy to find... again, not as easy as it used to be... but tolerable. Here's the problem though, adjustment is on a hairs edge. Any movement one way or the other will cause either slipping or drag... there's no margin on either side. I'm guessin that adjustment would be a constant, almost daily battle.
So.... on to V.2. I'll TIG the hole closed and re-drill it at 45MM. That's still 10MM better than the existing 35MM length.
As far as riding and shifting, it was almost effortless. Like a hot knife thru butter. :D

Interesting - and good info. Glad you are getting out on the bike a bit Jim.

Pete
 

billy icon

test pilot,gunnie pig, and all around experiment
Messages
475
Reaction score
943
Points
93
Location
mt hood OR
In school we had a name for girls like you. ;)

lol who me? I almost want to show you guys my conversion just so no one wasted anymore time and effort fiddling with these things, I do think all the mods to the worm drive are good and the different length on the actuator helps too, but my first time doing my "MOD" was out of necessity and the parts I had, and I only did it like I said to get to have a clutch with what I had, and the first pull I was amazed, and getting a good clean easy to find neutral was easier from then on too... I can spoil the fun..but I think when this one gets built the photos showing how I do it will be more better
 
Last edited:

5twins

XS650 Guru
Top Contributor
Messages
24,218
Reaction score
21,098
Points
813
Well, pictures will certainly be better than your writing, your posts are very hard to read and understand. Quit teasing us and show us "the goods" already.
 

billy icon

test pilot,gunnie pig, and all around experiment
Messages
475
Reaction score
943
Points
93
Location
mt hood OR
is it that bad for real, I know i have horrible grammar? but are they really hard to understand,? I will work on it, sorry I usually write these at the end of the work day when Im tired, and I look back on them the NeXT day and ask myself who wrote that a 5 year old Chinese kid. spell corrector helps with the spelling but isn't nothing gonna help my grammar, hopefully i can make up for the retardation with some funny moments and a bit of knowlege

and that's the thing is I don't have one apart to show you , but I will dismantle the one I did last time and show you guys how I went about it,
 

Jim

Beyond the edge is the unknown. Here be Dragons
Top Contributor
XS650.com Supporter
Messages
14,445
Reaction score
56,250
Points
813
Location
Kansas City Mo.
So... time for an update. Pulled the clutch actuator back out and filled the 50mm hole in. I don't remember who or where it was brought up, but there was a discussion recently about welding holes closed in relatively thin steel. I shared a trick an old welder showed me, so here's a pic of it. Clamp the sheet to a chunk of brass or copper. In this case, an old regulator valve body made of brass. fill the hole, grind it flat... flip it over and do it again. The piece never melts away 'cause the brass draws some of the heat off, and steel rod won't stick to the brass.

fix1.jpg


fix 3.jpg


fix2.jpg


fix 5.jpg



Re-drilled the hole at 45mm and put it all back together.


fix4.jpg



Pull is almost as easy as the 50mm length. Haven't tested it yet... unseasonably crappy weather... and more coming. Soon as I get to ride it I'll do an update.
 

2XSive

At least one screw loose behind the handle bars
Top Contributor
XS650.com Supporter
Messages
621
Reaction score
2,131
Points
243
Location
Michigan
Awesome tip Jim. I filed that one away in my memory bank. Looking good Jim!
 

Jim

Beyond the edge is the unknown. Here be Dragons
Top Contributor
XS650.com Supporter
Messages
14,445
Reaction score
56,250
Points
813
Location
Kansas City Mo.
So... looks like my last post was back in May 2020... oops... forgot all about this thread. Thanks for the memory jog @Mailman

I've run the bike two season now with the last configuration tried (comment #34)... that's the 45mm arm. Very happy with it. Pull is light (for our XS') and no clutch slip or drag. There is a lot of lever there, so the initial adjustment is a bit finicky, but once I got it dialed in it works just fine and doesn't change much, hot or cold. Shifting, including neutral is easy with no clunkiness. I'd attribute that more to the excellent Motion Pro cable than anything.

Still waiting on @billy icon to spill the beans on his super duper clutch actuator.
waiting.jpg

Two years is a looong tease. :sneaky:

Coming this spring, my next try at improving the clutch for us old arthritis challenged folk...


1644862321844.png



I'm happy with the current pull force, but it's almost a full lever. Very little left over on either end of engaged/disengaged. I'm hoping to cut that in half while keeping the light pull. The Enfield actuator uses ball bearings. Should be much smoother than the plastic worm setup. Stay tuned.
 
Last edited:

AUTOMAN

XS650 Member
Messages
27
Reaction score
27
Points
13
Location
Metamora,Mi.
So... looks like my last post was back in May 2020... oops... forgot all about this thread. Thanks for the memory jog @Mailman

I've run the bike two season now with the last configuration tried (comment #34)... that's the 45mm arm. Very happy with it. Pull is light (for our XS') and no clutch slip or drag. There is a lot of lever there, so the initial adjustment is a bit finicky, but once I got it dialed in it works just fine and doesn't change much, hot or cold. Shifting, including neutral is easy with no clunkiness. I'd attribute that more to the excellent Motion Pro cable than anything.

Still waiting on @billy icon to spill the beans on his super duper clutch actuator. View attachment 207399
Two years is a looong tease. :sneaky:

Coming this spring, my next try at improving the clutch for us old arthritis challenged folk...


View attachment 207400


I'm happy with the current pull force, but it's almost a full lever. Very little left over on either end of engaged/disengaged. I'm hoping to cut that in half while keeping the light pull. The Enfield actuator uses ball bearings. Should be much smoother than the plastic worm setup. Stay tuned.
You boys look in tech section?
8# 11# 15# vs. 29# 45# is the accept or reject limits?

cliff
 
Top